CURRENT WAIT TIME: 1-2 BUSINESS DAYS

Consignment

how it works

Are you ready to start consigning with Top Notch Sports Club?

Get the details on where to send your items, our fee breakdown, and other essential information.

Where to Send Your Items

Mail your items to the following address:

Top Notch Sports Club
8804 Tyler Boulevard, Mentor, OH 44060

Please keep in mind that if an item goes unsold for $0.99, it will not be returned.

Fee Breakdown

All fees are noted out the door with nothing additional! They are subject to change at any time ONLY if eBay changes fees (as of 3/29/21).

Sale

Fee

$0.99 - $999.99
18% + $0.75
$1000 - $2499.99
12%
$2500+
3% + $250

Returns

We will handle all returns. Once you sell your card(s) and get your money, we will not ask for it back!

Bidding

Absolutely no bidding on your own items or having anyone bid on your items. If we discover any wrongdoing, such as buying an item yourself or having a friend buy it and then return it just to make a sale, you will be held responsible and banned from consignments.

Payout

Once payment is received our website will update your totals in live time and you can be paid out. We will only pay out via check, wire, Zelle, ACH, and PayPal Goods.

Reminders

If your item is something that is often duplicated, we will not take any risks. We will make that decision once the item is in hand. If it’s raw, we will look at the condition. If it’s something we think may be returned, we will not list it!

Keep in mind:

  • $10 minimum value only!
  • Anything hit from a break can also be listed.
  • Anything sent to us that we cannot/will not list will be returned at your cost.
  • All items that do not sell for $0.99 will not be returned.

Do You Have Questions or Concerns?

Please contact us at support@topnotchsportsclub.com.

Copyright ©2026 Top Notch Sports Club